How much longer can the bleeding continue? That’s the question analysts and observers are wondering about the worsening state of Supervalu. The grim news continued last month as the Eden Prairie, MN retailers/wholesaler announced that it lost $202 million, or 95 cents per share, for the quarter ended December 4. That’s compared with a profit of $109 million, or 51 cents per share, in the same quarter last year. Supervalu recorded a huge $252 million in charges during the quarter, mainly to reflect its diminishing value and other intangible assets. The charges also covered store closing costs, employee severance and other items. Excluding the charges, the company earned 24 cents per share.
With the disappointing news, Wall Street and shareholders drove the stock to $7.34 per share that same day. Thirteen days later on January 25, the stock sank to a 25 year low, bottoming out at $7.06 per share. At presstime on February 4, SVU shares were selling at $7.31.
Overall sales decreased from $9.2 billion to $8.7 billion. At retail only, Supervalu’s third quarter net sales were $6.6 billion compared to $7.1 billion last year, a decrease of 7.7 percent, primarily reflecting the impact of identical store sales of negative 4.9 percent and previously announced market exits, the company stated. The identical store sales performance, Supervalu noted, resulted from a continued challenging economic environment and heightened competitive activity. Retail square footage decreased 4.1 percent from the third quarter of fiscal 2010. Excluding the impact of market exits and store closures, total retail square footage increased 1.0 percent compared to the third quarter of fiscal 2010.
The company also announced, in a follow-up conference call that both customer counts and transaction sizes continued to decline. On the conference call, Supervalu’s chief executive Craig Herkert also spoke of the importance of Supervalu veteran Janel Haugarth who has added responsibility of all corporate merchandising to her executive VP duties.
Just prior to the earnings call, Supervalu announced the February closings of 29 retail stores across the country, including 17 on the East Coast. Those include five Shoppers Food & Pharmacy units in the Baltimore-Washington market (Owings Mills, MD; Timonium, MD; Alexandria, VA (Penn Daw); Fredericksburg, VA; and Gainesville, VA); six Acme Markets (Limerick, PA; Wayne, PA; Cinnaminson, NJ: Millville, NJ; Moorestown, NJ: and Fallston, MD), five Shaw’s Supermarkets in New England (New Bedford, MA; Revere, MA; Stoneham, MA; Johnston, RI; and Warwick, RI);; and one Farm Fresh unit in downtown Norfolk, VA.
Herkert said, “Our performance is still not close to my expectations and we continue to take action to change the trajectory of our businesses. Through our business transformation process, we will invest in price, leverage our buying power and enhance retail execution. These measures underscore our commitment to deliver everyday value to our customers as we execute on our vision of being America’s Neighborhood Grocer.”
Third quarter supply chain services net sales were $2.1 billion, the same as last year.
Retail food net sales in the third quarter of fiscal 2011 represented 75.8 percent of net sales compared to 77.3 percent last year. Supply chain services net sales in the third quarter of fiscal 2011 represented 24.2 percent of net sales compared to 22.7 percent last year.
Gross profit was $1.9 billion in the third quarter, or 21.5 percent of net sales, compared to $2.1 billion or 22.4 percent last year. The decrease in gross margin as a percent of net sales reflects the shift in business segment mix and increased promotional spending.
Selling and administrative expenses in the third quarter were $1.72 billion, or 19.9 percent of net sales, including $63 million in pre-tax costs related to store exit, severance and labor buyout costs. Excluding these items, selling and administrative expenses were $1.66 billion, or 19.2 percent of sales. In the third quarter of fiscal 2010, selling and administrative expenses were $1.8 billion, or 19.0 percent of net sales, including a $22 million pre-tax net gain from the Salt Lake City retail market exit and $4 million in pre-tax costs related to store closures. Excluding these items, selling and administrative costs were $1.8 billion, or 19.2 percent of net sales. The benefit of business segment mix shift was offset by reduced sales leverage on expenses.
Goodwill and asset impairment charges of $240 million pre-tax were recorded in the third quarter and reflected in the retail food segment operating earnings. As a result, third quarter retail food operating loss was $153 million. Excluding the goodwill and asset impairment charge, as well as $59 million in pre-tax costs related to store closure and exit, severance and labor buyout costs, retail food operating earnings in the third quarter were $146 million, or 2.2 percent of net sales. Last year’s retail food operating earnings were $269 million, or 3.8 percent of net sales. Excluding the impact from the Salt Lake City retail market exit and store closures, retail food operating earnings were $251 million or 3.5 percent of net sales. The decrease in retail food operating earnings as a percent of net sales reflects increased promotional spending and reduced sales leverage on expenses.
Supply chain services operating earnings were $69 million, or 3.3 percent of sales, compared to $64 million, or 3.1 percent of sales last year. The increase in supply chain services operating earnings as a percent of net sales reflects strong expense management and improved productivity.
Net interest expense for the third quarter was $124 million compared to $131 million last year, reflecting reduced borrowing levels. The company remains in compliance with all debt covenants.
Supervalu’s income tax benefit was $21 million, or 9.2 percent of pre-tax loss in the third quarter compared to income tax expense of $68 million, or 38.8 percent of pre-tax income in last year’s third quarter. The tax rate for the third quarter of fiscal 2011 reflects the impact of the impairment charges, the majority of which is not deductible for tax purposes. Excluding the impact of the impairment charges and the sale of Bristol Farms, the tax rate for the third quarter of fiscal 2011 was 37.9 percent.
Capital spending for the third quarter was $142 million compared to $156 million in the prior year. In the third quarter the company completed 20 major remodels, 6 minor remodels and 1 new traditional supermarket, as well as 39 new Save-A-Lot locations. Year-to-date capital spending was $454 million compared to $552 million in the prior year.
Year-to-date net cash flows used for financing activities were $366 million compared to $449 million last year, primarily reflecting lower dividend payments in the current year.
Commenting on guidance, Herkert stated, “Our third quarter ID sales were softer than we had anticipated. We invested heavily in promotional activities that proved to be less than effective. As a result, it is prudent to take down our full-year guidance for ID sales and earnings.” Management now expects a net loss in fiscal 2011 in the range of $7.19 to $7.09 per diluted share on a GAAP basis and adjusted earnings of $1.25 to $1.35 per diluted share when excluding non-cash impairment charges and other costs. Supervalu’s fiscal 2011 guidance includes the following assumptions:
*Net sales for the 52-week fiscal year are estimated to be approximately $38 billion;
*Identical store sales growth, excluding fuel, is projected to be approximately negative 6.0 percent;
*Sales in the traditional food distribution business are expected to decline approximately 3.5 percent, primarily reflecting the transition of the Target Corporation volume to self distribution and the loss of Ukrop’s as a customer due to acquisition by a competitor;
*Consumer spending will continue to be pressured;
*Goodwill and intangible asset impairment charges are $1.8 billion pre-tax, or $1.7 billion after-tax;
*Fiscal 2011 will include the following approximate after-tax amounts per diluted share:
$0.38 in charges related to the completion of retail market exits in Connecticut and Cincinnati and store closure costs relating to the sale or closure of an additional 25 to 30 traditional retail stores;
*$0.12 in severance and labor buyout costs, including the elimination of administrative headcount in the fourth quarter;
*$0.11 in certain other costs related to the impact of a labor dispute at Shaw’s, which was resolved in July, and second quarter charges primarily for employee-related costs.
*$0.31 in gain on sale of Total Logistic Control.
*The effective tax rate is estimated to be approximately 37.4 percent, excluding impairment charges;
*Weighted-average diluted shares are estimated to be approximately 213 million for purposes of non-GAAP earnings per share;
*Capital spending is projected to be approximately $700 million, including 75 to 85 major store remodels, 15 to 25 minor remodels, 3 replacement stores and approximately 100 new hard-discount stores, including licensed locations, net of closures and relocations; and
*Debt reduction is projected to be approximately $850 million, including approximately $200 million of proceeds from the sale of Total Logistic Control.
Commenting on fiscal 2012 capital spending guidance, Herkert said, “We remain committed to aggressively paying down debt, investing in our asset base and shedding non-core operations. This coming year, we will again allocate greater capital to grow Save-A-Lot. For our traditional banners, capital spending will go toward investments in technology to support our business transformation and store remodels.”
The company announced its fiscal 2012 capital spending plan of approximately $700 million. Included in the plan are an acceleration of hard-discount store openings, including licensed locations, and 55 store remodels. No new traditional supermarkets are planned for fiscal 2012.