FMI research shows Americans feeling better about their supermarkets – despite near-overwhelming inflation concerns. But grocery operators shouldn’t confuse this with unconditional approval.
Americans have plenty of reasons to be unhappy with the economy. Consumer sentiment hit historic lows across all kinds of metrics in October.
But supermarkets, as it happens, are enjoying a moment in the bright sunshine of positive sentiment.
According to research presented by FMI – The Food Industry Association during a Nov. 12 media briefing, the organization’s U.S. Grocery Shopper Sentiment Index climbed to 72, up from 69 in August, even as broader consumer confidence remained “deeply depressed,” to put it mildly.
That’s certainly good news for the grocery industry, particularly after several years of inflation, rising operating costs and increasingly price-conscious customers.
But there’s reason to be skeptical about what those numbers are actually telling us. It’s not that – surprise! – consumers actually feel terrible about stores; the sentiment is very real. But we should be questioning the mechanics of how supermarkets are sparking those warm, fuzzy feelings.
FMI understandably sees improving grocery sentiment as evidence that supermarkets are meeting customer needs. That’s probably true. As we’ve seen, retailers have invested heavily in private brands, promotions, loyalty programs and other ways to help shoppers stretch their dollars.
But there’s another possibility: Consumers have simply become that much better at navigating an expensive grocery marketplace. What’s more, grocery shopping – a highly selective undertaking at the best of times – seems to offer a degree of control that households don’t really have over rising housing, insurance, utility and other expenses.
Those explanations aren’t mutually exclusive…
A Surprising Bright Spot in Consumer Sentiment
Heather Garlich, FMI’s senior vice president of communications, highlighted the improvement in grocery sentiment during the briefing, contrasting it with the University of Michigan’s broader Consumer Sentiment Index, which stood at a downright dismal 48 in October.
The two indices measure different things and use different methodologies, so their numerical scores don’t give us an apples to apples comparison.
Still, the contrasting readings are a story worth telling: Americans can be profoundly pessimistic about their financial circumstances while maintaining favorable opinions of the stores where they buy food.
FMI’s index measures shoppers’ feelings about grocery shopping and their relationships with their primary supermarkets. Garlich said consumers continue to give their stores strong ratings for helping them meet their needs. They seem to be extending supermarkets some measure of grace over price increases. And so a shopper can believe groceries cost too much while still loving the selection, service, convenience and discounts available at a particular supermarket.
Shoppers Are Worried, but They’re Adapting
The industry’s improving sentiment score certainly doesn’t mean consumers have stopped worrying about food prices. FMI found that 62% of shoppers believe their incomes are falling behind inflation, while 65% remain extremely or very concerned about rising grocery prices. Another 72% said they are doing okay financially… provided they stick to their budgets.
I think the most revealing finding for this discussion was that 88% of shoppers now feel they have at least some control over their grocery shopping. That’s an increase of 13 percentage points since August.
Consumers may not be able to do much about their electricity bills, insurance premiums or mortgage payments. Grocery shopping, by comparison, offers numerous opportunities to make adjustments. Put another way, I’m thoroughly stuck when my power utility inexplicably jacks up my bill by 15%, but I’m firmly in the driver’s seat when I hunt down and score a great deal on shredded wheat at the grocery store.
Shoppers can switch brands, buy less expensive cuts of meat, purchase private-label products, change package sizes, stock up during promotions or visit other stores. None of those strategies makes inflation disappear. But they give consumers choices, and those choices can make a difficult financial situation feel more manageable.
Supermarkets Deserve Some Credit
It would be unfair to suggest retailers have played no part in that improvement.
Supermarkets have expanded private-brand assortments, sharpened promotional programs and invested in technology intended to help customers identify savings. (The challenge now is making sure everyone has access to that value.)
FMI’s Steve Markenson estimated that private brands now account for roughly 25% of grocery store sales, up from around 15% to 16% a decade ago. Those products provide shoppers with alternatives to national brands, although private label nowadays includes premium merchandise, not just lower-priced substitutes.
Loyalty programs also provide meaningful value to participating customers. FMI reported that roughly three-quarters of enrolled shoppers consider their primary store’s program extremely or highly valuable. As we’re seeing this holiday season, retailers are developing lower-cost meal solutions and promotions designed to help families maintain traditional celebrations without spending as much.
This is a wildly competitive business, and maintaining customer goodwill while managing higher labor, transportation, energy and merchandise costs is no small accomplishment.
Loyalty Has Its Limits
FMI’s own research offers a compelling reason not to over-interpret the industry’s improved standing: According to Markenson, shoppers visit an average of 5.4 grocery banners across four retail channels during a typical 30-day period.
These folks spend approximately 70% of their grocery dollars at their primary store, doling out the remaining 30% among other retailers. That’s a lot of spending taking place outside the whatever retailer a household considers its main grocery destination.
It’s possible a shopper may appreciate a neighborhood supermarket’s produce department, prepared foods and customer service… while buying paper products at Costco, pantry staples at Aldi and household necessities at Walmart or Target. These days the primary supermarket can remain a valued destination without capturing the entire grocery budget.
Its seems plausible that the mere ability to shop among competing retailers may itself contribute to consumers’ growing sense of control.
Satisfaction Isn’t a Blank Check
The grocery industry’s improving sentiment numbers are encouraging – good news at a time when that’s in short supply. A victory lap wouldn’t be inappropriate. Just be careful about claiming too much credit.
The FMI research clearly establishes that shoppers feel more positive about grocery shopping and more capable of managing their purchases. What’s not so clear is how much of that improvement comes from retailers’ efforts, consumers’ own resourcefulness or the simple fact that grocery shopping offers more flexibility than many other household expenses.
Don’t underestimate the underlying economic anxiety, either. It remains… substantial, with so many worried about prices and income. That’s hardly a ringing endorsement of the current cost of feeding a household. The important thing is not to confuse goodwill with unconditional loyalty; shoppers may love their supermarkets, but they’re pretty good at finding alternatives.
