The food industry has developed an elaborate system for justifying food price increases but no real mechanism for reversing them. Manufacturers, retailers and even Wall Street have reasons to protect those increases, even when commodity costs decline.
The food industry is good at explaining why prices need to increase, but it’s less than enthusiastic about explaining why they should come down.
When beef, wheat, sugar or coffee prices climb, manufacturers have plenty of data handy to justify passing along higher costs. Retailers review the requests, negotiate where they can and eventually adjust their shelf prices.
But when those same commodity costs come down, prices don’t reset. The next commodity change becomes a new round of price increases and cumulative effect is ever increasing price increases. The price of cheese is a good example, the biggest part of the cost of cheese is generally milk, yet the cost of Class 3 milk has been relatively stable for 10 years (with highs and lows ), but the cost at retail has grown 14.5%. Certainly a lot also has to be increased freight costs, and other costs, but these do not account for all of the increased prices added over time. The reality is there is no reset on commodity adjusted prices for finished CPG products, they simply accumulate over time.
Why Prices Rise Faster Than They Fall
Economists call this “asymmetric price transmission,” sometimes described as the “rockets and feathers” effect. You could say prices surge like rockets when costs increase but drift down like feathers when costs decline.
Research by the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Economic Research Service (ERS) has documented asymmetric price adjustments in food markets. In a study of beef and bread prices covering 1972 through 2008, researchers found that retail prices sometimes responded differently to increases and decreases in wholesale costs. During 2000–2008, retail beef prices incorporated approximately 19% to 29% of changes in wholesale beef prices, while retail bread prices incorporated approximately 16% to 21% of changes in wholesale flour prices.
That alone doesn’t confirm that every food price rises faster than it falls. However, it does tell us that changing commodity costs don’t translate into immediate, proportionate changes in the grocery aisles.
There are perfectly legitimate reasons for the imbalance. Agricultural commodities represent only part of the cost of manufacturing and distributing food. Labor, packaging, transportation and other expenses may be moving in the opposite direction. Contracts and inventory have the potential to delay price adjustments, too.
I’m not saying supermarkets should rewrite their price files every time commodity futures move, but those complications I mentioned shouldn’t exempt manufacturers and retailers from taking a hard look at whether lower costs justify lower prices.
There’s a Manufacturer-Retailer Standoff
Picture a manufacturer whose primary ingredient costs go down significantly. In theory, the company could reduce its selling price to retailers.
But what happens next?
A retailer on the receiving end of that lower acquisition cost can reduce the everyday shelf price, improve its gross margin or support competitive pricing elsewhere in the store. They have options. For them, it’s a great position to be in.
But from the manufacturer’s perspective, that creates an uncomfortable proposition: I don’t know exactly what the retailer’s going to do; maybe they’ll pocket the savings without ginning up additional consumer demand. Why should I surrender revenue voluntarily if that’s the case? And lowering prices for a lower price everyday is a long term build, competing against someone on sale that week is easier by offering more promotions – what is lost in this is eventually is in most CPG categories something is always on promotion, the idea that you might give up everyday margin for everyday retail is lost in what your get in volume from a big sale – but at some point you can only promote so much to effect sales. Historically the idea from manufacturers was if you spend big you get repeated purchases at full revenue, I personally doubt that view that given outside of the giants of the grocery industry (mostly consumer products goods like P & G) few have real brand power, they have product power in a few items (think Valvetta for Rotelle, certain products like Pampers where you have to have the exact product to meet your needs The Kroger and Red Bull disagreement might test this my thought. Red Bull is a marketing machine, not seen in decades. We will see how that works out.
There’s evidence that higher grocery prices don’t always reflect higher operating costs alone.
In its 2024 report, Feeding America in a Time of Crisis, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) found that food and beverage retailers’ revenues exceeded total costs by more than 6% in 2021 and approximately 7% during the first three quarters of 2023, compared with a previous peak of 5.6% in 2015.
The regulator questioned whether rising expenses fully explained higher grocery prices, although it didn’t establish that retailers systematically withheld wholesale savings from consumers. The findings reinforce an uncomfortable truth: a relationship between costs and shelf prices isn’t always straightforward.
The manufacturer can point to the retailer. The retailer can point to other expenses or pricing investments. They can both argue that they’re protecting their businesses. All the while there’s not much transparency about what transpired between the manufacturer’s invoice and the grocery shelf.
How Wall Street Muddies the Waters
There’s another influence on food pricing, particularly among the big publicly traded CPG manufacturers: Wall Street.
Among other things, investors evaluate companies on revenue growth, operating margins and earnings. Management teams are expected to improve financial performance against the previous quarter or year.
Yesterday’s price increase is today’s revenue baseline.
In other words, what began as a necessary response to rising commodity costs has become part of the financial performance management must defend to shareholders. If those commodities subsequently decline, reducing prices may put pressure on revenue and margins even though the original justification has weakened.
Lower prices could stimulate unit sales or help recover market share, but those benefits are uncertain and, besides, they take time to materialize. In a world that lives quarter-to-quarter, the immediate effect on earnings is easier to measure.
That doesn’t mean investors invariably reward manufacturers for maintaining higher prices. They also watch volumes and market share. A company with fortress-like margins that loses customers will almost certainly face pressure to change course.
But there’s a difference between reducing prices because deteriorating sales force the issue and voluntarily returning savings because the costs that justified an earlier increase have declined. One is a response to business performance. The other calls for management to take some initiative.
No One Is Looking Out for the Shopper
According to the U.S. Census Bureau, median household income reached $87,460 in 2025. Separately, USDA research found that households in the middle-income quintile spent an average of $9,097 on food in 2024. That represents about 12.2% of pretax income. But for households in the lowest income quintile, food accounted for 33% of pretax income.
That’s why even modest price changes can have a deep impact.
Every participant in the supply chain has a rational reason to protect profitability, but who’s responsible for ensuring that lower costs benefit the consumer?
The answer, apparently, is… everybody in principle and nobody in particular. And that’s the structural problem. The industry has established well-oiled-machine processes for requesting, reviewing and implementing price increases. But there’s far less visible discipline when it comes to determining when previous increases are no longer justified.
Time for a New Conversation About Pricing
Part of the solution is straightforward: Manufacturers and retailers need to spend more time talking about pricing. It’s not a dirty word.
Much of the administrative work associated with price changes now moves through vendor portals, electronic submissions and automated systems. These tools improve efficiency, but processing a price change isn’t the same as taking a hard look at whether it makes economic sense.
That’s not to say technology is the problem; a pricing portal can process a decrease just as readily as an increase. But people need to look actively for opportunities to initiate one. There should be more substantive conversations when commodity costs decline, particularly after an earlier increase was justified by those same commodities movements.
If manufacturers continue to face higher labor or packaging expenses, retailers should understand that. If lower ingredient costs have created room for a reduction, that deserves equal consideration. After all, retailers are, ultimately, the fall guy when it comes to consumer perceptions of price; manufacturers rarely take the blame.
And if a manufacturer lowers its selling price, both parties should discuss how the savings might reach consumers, whether that’s via everyday prices, promotions or broader investments in value.
Not a single one of these recommendations requires manufacturers or retailers to sacrifice profitability – or pass along every commodity decline dollar for dollar.
It does call for a change in emphasis, though.
When commodity costs decline, someone should ask whether the savings can reach the shelf. When a manufacturer reduces its selling price, someone should ask what happens to the difference. The industry has a well-established process for raising prices. It’s time to develop an effective process for determining when to lower them.
Ultimately, retailers receive the blame for higher grocery prices from both consumers and politicians. Neither blames higher cost on a single manufacturer, but all blame the retailer they shop at. It’s not fair to the retailers, and ultimately both manufacturers and retailers should try to address the overall basket cost to feed the consumers.
