The Value Shopper Has Expensive Taste

6 Min Read

The Specialty Food Association’s 2027 trend forecast suggests shoppers are finding room for premium ingredients in otherwise inexpensive meals. New merchandising opportunities abound… 

As we’ve seen, grocery shoppers are, almost universally, keeping a watchful eye on their spending. At the same time, they’re buying premium foods – they seem to be getting more selective about where they spend their money.

A shopper unwilling to spend $25 on dinner might happily fork over $12 for a jar of chili crisp that transforms a dozen inexpensive meals. Rice, eggs, beans and pasta are by and large still affordable staples, but a specialty condiment, finishing oil or simmer sauce can make those familiar foods feel like something worth ordering at a restaurant.

The Specialty Food Association (SFA) identifies this behavior as one of four major trends in its Specialty Food Trends: 2027 Forecast. They call it  “Instant Elevation.”

It makes sense. Grocery prices are up approximately 29% since 2020, according to the report. So, it follows that consumers are looking for ways to maintain the enjoyment of restaurant-quality food without the expense of dining out.

This is a straightforward merchandising opportunity for on-trend grocery operators: sell an affordable meal alongside one premium ingredient  to sweeten the deal – and make the entire purchase more appealing.

Saving on Staples, Splurging on Flavor

To get to grips with what’s happening, it’ll be helpful to throw out the old distinction between “value” and “premium” shoppers. Consumers can be highly price-sensitive about everyday staples while showing more flexibility when purchasing a specialty ingredient that delivers  something special.

Consider that $12 jar of chili crisp I mentioned. If it improves 20 meals, the incremental cost is just 60 cents per serving – a world away from asking shoppers to trade up to premium products across an entire grocery basket.

SFA’s forecast suggests consumers are keeping the foundation of their meals simple and concentrating discretionary spending on ingredients that deliver flavor, convenience and a sense of occasion.

The association also cites a 52% increase in solo dining since 2021, suggesting that consumers are willing to invest in meals they prepare or enjoy just for themselves. In light of this, it’s easy to see how  demonstrating how a product improves familiar foods could be more effective than emphasizing its premium positioning alone.

Put the Upgrade Next to the Staple

The trouble is, in many cases, specialty products are merchandised separately from the inexpensive foods they complement. In those cases, a shopper purchasing, say, rice might never encounter the chili crisp because it’s stocked several aisles away. Someone buying canned white beans might overlook a finishing oil or simmer sauce that could turn those beans into dinner.

SFA recommends bringing those products together through what it calls “Upgrade Pairings.”

Chili crisp could be displayed alongside rice and eggs, finishing oils near canned beans and global hot sauces beside tortillas. In all cases, the objective should be to make the connection between an inexpensive staple and a premium ingredient immediately apparent.

The association also proposes a merchandising concept called “The $3 Dinner,” using in-store signage to demonstrate how shoppers can assemble affordable meals with one specialty addition. The number is a selling point; showing the cost per serving gives shoppers a practical reason to consider a product they might otherwise dismiss as too expensive.

For example, a supermarket could promote a simple pasta dinner featuring specialty pesto, while illustrating how the sauce can be used across several meals.

Making the Most of Small Indulgences

The strategy could be particularly useful for conventional supermarkets competing against discounters and warehouse clubs on everyday grocery prices.

Rather than attempting to match every competitor’s price, retailers can differentiate themselves through product discovery, culinary inspiration and merchandising that helps customers get more enjoyment from their grocery spending.

SFA also recommends entertaining bundles featuring cheese, crackers, compotes and serving suggestions, as well as gift-ready specialty products for shoppers visiting friends or family.

There are limits to the opportunity. Not every shopper can justify a $12 condiment, and the SFA report doesn’t establish how many consumers are adopting this particular spending pattern.

But the underlying proposition is compelling here. We’ve seen lower prices, larger packages, and discounts, but “Instant Elevation” offers another approach: showing shoppers how a relatively small premium purchase can improve several inexpensive meals. In other words, sometimes the most effective way to sell a $12 specialty product is to put it next to a $1 bag of rice.

Share This Article
Duke Winston brings decades of firsthand experience across the grocery industry, with deep institutional knowledge developed through years of working alongside retailers, wholesalers, manufacturers, and industry leaders. A longtime contributor to Food Trade News market studies and special reports, he provides practical insight into competitive dynamics, market evolution, and the strategic decisions shaping the food industry.